Michael B.
6/23/2021
Whenever you see prime rib and lobster tail for under $40... you get a little leary. Not in this case! It is a decent rib and the lobster tail, according to my wife is heavenly. I'm not the...
Captain John's Restaurant & Tiki Bar
$$$
Closed
(58)
Photos
1424 Main St
Sylvan Beach, NY 13157
Captain John's Restaurant & Tiki Bar in Sylvan Beach, NY offers an immersive island experience with its Shipwreck Tiki Bar and Grill, where guests can enjoy a new outdoor dining patio and indulge in a delicious menu.
With its vibrant island vibes, Captain John's is the go-to destination for those seeking a fun-filled experience, complete with special offers and a travel store to enhance their visit.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.058 reviewsAnthony G.
12/29/2024
Fantastic food and service. Absolutely beautiful atmosphere. I go to Captain John's weekly in the summer
Kelly H.
5/2/2025
The food was definitely overpriced and adequate at best. The owner did not want to accommodate a request to split a bill three ways for a party of 12. Thankfully the waitress accommodated us. The...
Cindy C.
5/12/2023
05.12.23 Friday @ 7:30pm. Table for 6 Our server seems newly hired and can see he's trying his best. Sweet and friendly. 2x steam clams - was over cooked as of chewing rubber. 1x fresh clams -...
Jim S.
9/6/2024
Prime rib was a reheat ! Waitress was very friendly and efficient. Sad piece of meat for $49
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.