Eric C.
10/13/2025
Excellent place. I really hope they stick around. The cortado hit the spot and my wife and I loved the affogatos. Service was excellent. I love how spacious the vibe is. Go. It's worth it.
Caffinated New Yorker
Closed
(9)
Photos
523 Bay St
Staten Island, NY 10304
Caffinated New Yorker is a cozy eatery located in Staten Island NY where coffee lovers and food enthusiasts unite. This charming spot offers a diverse menu featuring artisanal coffee fresh breakfast options and delicious lunch items all served in a welcoming atmosphere. With its vibrant decor and friendly staff it’s the perfect place to relax grab a bite or catch up with friends.
Generated from this place's information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.59 reviews
Amanda W.
5/11/2025
Coffeee is good but the pastries are mid, my blueberrry scone is ehh, and the ham and cheese croissant was just ok. The service was nice and decor was good but I don't love it, its a big space and...
Hasti P.
5/22/2025
Cozy little spot with quality coffee & variety of pastries. Definitely one of the nicest coffee shops on the island (although the neighborhood is not ideal) but I hope they thrive.
Liu H.
10/4/2024
New lovely cafe at Stapleton, Staten Island! For those of you who are looking for a cute cafe with great selection of pasties, drinks and a space to gather to sit down and chill. Caffeinated...
Rhea Z.
2/6/2025
Very cute inside. Such a warm vibe for sure. This would be a great spot to do some work on a laptop or just to sip your coffee. Service was good. Barista was very nice. I quite didn't like that...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.