Glenda E.
7/25/2025
My daughter recently had her 9th birthday party at Buttermilk Bakeshop! Let me tell you, my daughter said it was the "best birthday ever". The baking class party was a really great fit and choice...
Buttermilk Bakeshop
$
Open
(381)
Photos
260 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11215
Buttermilk Bakeshop is a cozy bakery in Brooklyn, NY that specializes in crafting delicious baked goods. Their menu features a variety of sweet and savory treats made with high-quality ingredients.
Customers can enjoy a warm and inviting atmosphere while indulging in freshly baked pastries, cakes, and other confections. Buttermilk Bakeshop is a go-to spot for those seeking a delightful and satisfying bakery experience in the heart of Brooklyn.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5381 reviews
Melody C.
9/19/2025
Got a lemon lavender cake from here because Google reviewers kept raving about this flavor. The lemon flavor was more obvious than the lavender, but I enjoyed the flavor nevertheless. However, it...
Natalie J.
5/12/2025
My husband a Lemon Tiramisu cake for my birthday. Can I just say I had the worst birthday cake ever. What a great start... Anyways, so I called the cakeshop directly and it was an employee. She...
Anya T.
12/30/2024
This is the only home made bakery cookie that tastes like a chip's ahoy cookie. You know that weird packaged taste some bake goods have when they're mass produced. Somehow this cookie had that...
Heather R.
5/4/2025
Buttermilk Bakeshop is very cute bakery located in beautiful parkslope Brooklyn. I purchased some chocolate and vanilla cupcakes and gluten free chocolate chip cookies for some company. Everyone...
See a problem?
