Kari B.
6/14/2025
AWESOME store! Very convenient and FRESH food. Cashier Chris was very helpful and polite. Will definitely come back again!
Buttercup's Dairy Store
$
Open
(55)
Photos
285 Boyle Rd
Port Jefferson Station, NY 11784
Buttercup's Dairy Store in Port Jefferson Station, NY, is a beloved family-owned establishment, rooted in tradition since the 1930s. Originally a dairy farm, it has evolved into a one-stop shop, offering fresh baked goods, deli meats, and locally sourced produce to the community.
Known for its quality and commitment to customer satisfaction, Buttercup's provides a range of options from daily specials to catering services for various events. With a focus on fresh ingredients and homemade flavors, the store continues to be an essential part of the neighborhood's culinary landscape.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.055 reviews
Mike G.
12/21/2024
First off we really like this store anyway but this week we catered a holiday party and decided to order a 4' hero and it was the best party hero I've ever had. Awesome. Forget the other places...
Nancy F.
2/3/2025
Love shopping here! They have a great variety of prepared foods, delicious breads, cookies, pies and full service deli too! Also precut deli meats if you're on the run!
Michele P.
6/11/2024
So anyone ever ordered a GROSS 3FT HERO?? WELL .. THIS IS THE PLACE TO GET ONE!! We ordered a chicken hero for a party and the bread crumbs were white and the chicken was not sliced. It was just...
Bruce B.
9/5/2022
Love this place. It's like a miniature supermarket. Great baked goods and a little bit of everything. Read some of the negative comments. Nothing but picky shit.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.