Lulu B.
11/3/2025
Absolutely delicious baked goods. No need to travel 45 minutes to that place out east. The Dutch Apple pie is to die for. Their website indicates that they carry strawberry rhubarb as a special...
Buttercup's Dairy Store
$
Open
(56)
Photos
285 Boyle Rd
Port Jefferson Station, NY 11784
Buttercup's Dairy Store in Port Jefferson Station, NY, is a beloved family-owned establishment, rooted in tradition since the 1930s. Originally a dairy farm, it has evolved into a one-stop shop, offering fresh baked goods, deli meats, and locally sourced produce to the community.
Known for its quality and commitment to customer satisfaction, Buttercup's provides a range of options from daily specials to catering services for various events. With a focus on fresh ingredients and homemade flavors, the store continues to be an essential part of the neighborhood's culinary landscape.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.556 reviews
Mike G.
12/21/2024
First off we really like this store anyway but this week we catered a holiday party and decided to order a 4' hero and it was the best party hero I've ever had. Awesome. Forget the other places...
Kari B.
6/14/2025
AWESOME store! Very convenient and FRESH food. Cashier Chris was very helpful and polite. Will definitely come back again!
Nancy F.
2/3/2025
Love shopping here! They have a great variety of prepared foods, delicious breads, cookies, pies and full service deli too! Also precut deli meats if you're on the run!
Michele P.
6/11/2024
So anyone ever ordered a GROSS 3FT HERO?? WELL .. THIS IS THE PLACE TO GET ONE!! We ordered a chicken hero for a party and the bread crumbs were white and the chicken was not sliced. It was just...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.