Brothers Trattoria

$$
Open
yelp logo

(53)

Photos

2540 Route 55
Poughquag, NY 12570

Reviews

yelp logo
4.553 reviews
Photo of Tom T.
Tom T.
10/18/2025

A recent NextDoor question asked what people thought our best local pizza is. It's a no brainer for me. This place. But Brothers is more than just pizza, offering a nice range of dishes. I've...

Photo of Enxhi B.
Enxhi B.
9/27/2024

Came here with the family for dinner before they went on vacation for 2 weeks, lol. Had previously been to Brothers Trattoria in Beacon, but this one in Poughquag was closer to my fam's house, so...

Joseph S.
9/28/2025

Pizza rivals the best from NYC. Excellent dishes to to taste and magnificent customer service.

Photo of Kate W.
Kate W.
5/21/2025

I love eating here. My favorite dish is the hot and spicy shrimp with the crostini . I go to that restaurant just for that as a matter of fact, I'm gonna see if I can go by today and maybe order...

Photo of Bronxy G.
Bronxy G.
11/30/2024

I popped in with a friend and had a good meal, good wine and great service. I liked the spacious dining room easy to hear during our conversation (not the lighting so much it was at a level that...

Own this business?
See a problem?
United StatesNew YorkPoughquagBrothers Trattoria