Boxcar Barney's

$
Closed
yelp logo

(54)

Call
Website

Photos

13 W Lake Rd
Mayville, NY 14757
+1 (716) 222-9925
https://www.boxcarbarneysicecream.com

Boxcar Barney's is a beloved ice cream shop located in Mayville, NY, offering a wide variety of delicious flavors and mouthwatering desserts.

With a loyal following and a commitment to quality, Boxcar Barney's has become a go-to destination for ice cream lovers in the area.

Generated from the website

Reviews

yelp logo
4.554 reviews
Helene K.
8/9/2025

Wonderful flavors generous portions! Get the flight! Bargain 6 different flavors yummmmmm

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Michael T.
Michael T.
8/9/2024

Great little "boxcar" near the lake in Westfield NY. Humongous ice cream cones and soft serve. Excellent place to bring the kids.

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Jack G.
Jack G.
6/28/2024

This ice cream may be the best I have had in my entire life. Every one of it's flavors are delicious(I know this because my family tried many many samples) but finally we decided. I ordered a...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Lori T.
Lori T.
6/15/2024

Cute place to go across from lakeside park. Great variety of flavors and quality. Reminds me of Handles in Ohio. Cashier was very helpful with selection. Pistachio is the bomb! Lots of nuts!!

Read more on Yelp
Photo of David A.
David A.
11/25/2023

Been to a lot of ice cream stands over the years and nothing beats this place. It's so good that we planned on driving 2-1/2 hours at the end of summer to have one more taste before winter. That...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Pdi Cone
Eating places, Fast food restaurants and stands, Delicatessen (eating places)

Pdi Cone

$
PDI Cone - Dutch Treat LLC is a Buffalo-based company that specializes in providing a wide range of delicious ice cream cones, toppings, and accessories. With a strong emphasis on customer support and satisfaction, they confidently offer a money-back guarantee on all their products. From whole peanut butter cups to chopped Heath pieces and a variety of cookie bases, PDI Cone offers an extensive selection of toppings that cater to every ice cream lover's taste. With their commitment to quality and a diverse range of options, PDI Cone ensures that it's always better on a sugar cone.Generated from the website
Farmer's Daughter
Fast food restaurants and stands, Eating places, Ice cream (packaged)

Farmer's Daughter

16
•
$
"Great road side stop. The burgers and fries were excellent! Fresh and delicious! Many ice cream choices. Staff helpful and pleasant."
Route 20 Ice Cream
Eating places, Fast food restaurants and stands, Ice cream stands or dairy bars

Route 20 Ice Cream

38
•
$
"Oh my ICE CREAM GOODNESS!!! Route 20 Ice Cream made these two brothers oh so happy!!! My brother wanted "custard" so I yelped and found Route 20 was minutes away. Pulling in you can't help but..."
photo of Dave D.
United States›New York›Mayville›Boxcar Barney's

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.