Farrah A.
8/22/2025
Great little coffee, bagel, and lunch spot in North Fork-specifically, Cutchogue. My friends are North Fork residences and hosted us for a long and lovely weekend; Black Sheep is their prefered...
Black Sheep Bagles - Cutchogue
Closed
(23)
Photos
31000 Main Rd
Cutchogue, NY 11935
Black Sheep Bagels, with locations in Jamesport and Cutchogue, NY, is dedicated to providing quality bagels made fresh every day. Their diverse menu includes breakfast and lunch sandwiches, a variety of spreads and toppings, as well as pastries and acai bowls.
Focused on excellent customer service, Black Sheep Bagels aims to create a welcoming environment for guests to enjoy flavorful meals any time of day. Whether for a quick breakfast or a leisurely lunch, their offerings are designed to satisfy a range of tastes.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.023 reviews
Victoria S.
8/26/2025
Great bagels and delicious coffee!! Wish they could do something about all the bees outside - but it's Mother Nature.
P D.
9/23/2025
Best bagels and flagels on Long Island!!! Fast service and great assortment of bagels and flagels. Plus the great appetizers and they deliver!
Linda A.
8/12/2025
Kudos to Black Sheep bagels! They did such an amazing job catering a luncheon party last weekend. Bobby and Krishna could not have been more helpful and accommodating. I made many changes along...
David D.
8/19/2025
long have i lived in nyc. many a bagels have i consumed. Black Sheep is among the very best. probably my number 1. perfect size. crunch. chew. that unspoken flavor of great dough. i eat them...
See a problem?
