Black Sheep Bagels

$
Closed
yelp logo

(31)

Call
Website

Photos

1451 Main Rd
Riverhead, NY 11901
+1 (631) 779-2914
https://theoriginalgoldbergsbagels.com

Black Sheep Bagels, nestled in Riverhead, NY, is a cozy and inviting bakery that specializes in crafting delectable bagels. Established with a rich history in 1949, the roots of this family-run business are deeply entwined in the art of flour, water, and yeast. Through four generations, the Goldberg family has elevated the humble bagel, bringing it into the modern era.

Rooted in tradition, Black Sheep Bagels pays homage to Arthur 'Artie' Goldberg, who paved the way with his expertise as a baker, bagel maker, and store owner. The legacy continued with Marc Goldberg, who honed his skills from a young age, embodying the values of hard work instilled by his father. With a commitment to quality and service, the Goldberg family offers a diverse array of deli and bakery delights to the Eastern Long Island community.

Generated from the website content

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.531 reviews
Photo of J C.
J C.
7/7/2025

Best Bacon Egg & Cheese salt pepper ketchup, be sure to visit Natasha, she is awesome! Thanks for the great sandwich see you tomorrow~ Cowboy

Read more on Yelp
A G.
5/29/2025

Well... was being helped this morning by a young woman... I asked for 2bagels and 1 bialy ... total... wait for it... $8.50!! Nothing on them mind you. Me " you want the for the 3 " Response......

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Vincent P.
Vincent P.
9/2/2023

Ok so I'm from queens and we have banging bagel places so understand this review is coming from someone that knows a good quality bagel. My girlfriend and I were heading out to the wineries and...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Nicole F.
Nicole F.
10/9/2024

Delicious!!!! Every few months when we drive out for our trip to Southold, we make it a point to stop at Black Sheep bagels. Whether it's the one in Riverhead or the one in Cutchogue, The Bagels...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Stephanie F.
Stephanie F.
9/30/2024

Ordered as a group yesterday. The bagels were good but ordered the Southampton hero. Asked for no Peter Luger sauce or tomato, when we received the sandwich it was clear they put the sauce on the...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Strathmore Bagels
Eating places, Bagels

Strathmore Bagels

75
•
$
"I give it 3 starts for offering no gluten kneaded bagels, they are amazing and love they support another local business. Where I take issue is that they like to close early on Sundays. We have..."
photo of Luciana R.
Devine's Bagels & Cafe
Eating places, Delicatessen (eating places), Cafe

Devine's Bagels & Cafe

114
•
$
"Bagels were good but the customer service was not warm and friendly but efficient and delivered my bagel with haste."
photo of Casper W.
Village Bagels
Eating places, Delicatessen (eating places), Bagels

Village Bagels

50
•
$
"The New Yorker in me can't quite give it a full five stars--being from Long Island, I know just how good a bagel can be. That said, they did a damn good job. Easily the most stacked bagel with lox..."
United States›New York›Riverhead›Black Sheep Bagels

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.