Chrstina F.
10/2/2025
Food and service was okay. Outside dining was on the water. Very casual. Seating was very tight but it was summertime.
Billys By the Bay
$$
Closed
(171)
Photos
2530 Manhasset Ave
Greenport, NY 11944
Billy's by the Bay is a fresh seafood and lobster restaurant located in Greenport, NY, within the picturesque Safe Harbor Marina. Known for its welcoming service and casual Key West style atmosphere, the eatery is dedicated to providing a delightful dining experience for all visitors.
Open daily, Billy's offers live music entertainment each evening, enhancing the laid-back vibe of the venue. The restaurant prides itself on serving the freshest seafood on the North Fork, ensuring that guests enjoy a true taste of the region.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.0171 reviews
Warren L.
7/21/2025
This is not a fancy place. However for a dockside restaurant its just right. Service was very prompt. Food kinda is what it is. Some fried clam strips. Scallops wrapped in bacon. And raw...
Caroline R.
10/11/2025
The food was horrible The manager extremely rude and impolite They are " from the manager" serving the world famous and acclaimed lobster roll in the area ...avoid them ...this is disgusting....
John F H.
8/28/2025
Always a great time here. Food above average. Service always impeccable. Beer drinks always perfect. Entertainment is great as well. Definitely stop here for their seafood as well as their...
Alden G.
5/23/2025
Authentic fish camp feel - friendly hard-working staff, draft beers. Outstanding lobster rolls and assorted seafoods. It's all good!
See a problem?
