Jessica P.
8/15/2025
I LOVE this ice cream place! The staff is friendly, and they have so many interesting and unique ice cream flavors. I went with Campfire S'mores this time and loved it. Textures are perfect,...
Big Papa's Creamery
$$
(16)
Photos
Lancaster, NY 14086
Big Papa's Creamery is a renowned ice cream parlor located in Lancaster, NY, specializing in handcrafted artisan ice cream. They offer a delightful selection of premium flavors that cater to a variety of tastes and dietary preferences, including a rich dairy-free salted caramel option.
In addition to their delectable ice cream, Big Papa's Creamery also provides services for private events, making it a perfect choice for weddings, birthdays, and corporate gatherings. Their unique and over-the-top ice cream experience is designed to leave a sweet impression on guests at any celebration.
Generated from the website
Reviews
5.016 reviews
Connie P.
8/3/2025
We saw a segment on a local news channel and it looked so good and homemade flavors! Which are good for you! They are located in the heart of the village of Lancaster. Its a nice cute location....
Khristina S.
6/10/2025
Patient and friendly staff, and great selection of standard & unique ice cream flavors. A fun environment with a uniform-dressed skeleton at the window, bright lights & mirrors. Pricey but tasty...
Susan N.
9/3/2025
Great addition to the Lancaster area! They have so many wonderful flavors. I brought my dog last time and he really enjoyed his pup cup!
Mary C. S.
9/16/2025
Tried out the new fixed location recently. The store is light and airy, with huge windows. The friendly staff will answer any questions you might have. A single cone/dish is $3. I was a little...
See a problem?
