Big Gay Ice Cream

Permanently closed
yelp logo

(15)

Website

Photos

353 W 14th St
New York, NY 10014

Find related places

Reviews

yelp logo
3.515 reviews
Photo of George C.
George C.
2/22/2017

They've wisely 86'd the larger sizes, but the receipt still has an oddity: "New York, OH"...Alas, they seem to be struggling despite the smart menu changes, so hopefully they last as a solid...

Photo of Katie H.
Katie H.
9/8/2017

I tried this place for the first time, but I understand that this location is nothing like their other locations. I chose to go with a pint of their ice cream because they offered an interesting...

Photo of Mike C.
Mike C.
9/29/2016

New Big Gay is finally open! The specialty here is their shakes, and as they were quick to point out on insta, they are made with "no mounds of crap on them". Indeed, they are very simple and...

Photo of Sarah N.
Sarah N.
4/24/2017

How does this place have less than 5 stars? Have they even tried the Bea Arthur? It's kind of pricey but completely WORTH it. Good old fashioned soft serve realness in delicious cones.

Photo of Whitney P.
Whitney P.
1/18/2017

Three stars because while this cone was delicious, I can't justify six dollars for a soft serve ice cream cone. It's soft serve vanilla, dulce de leche on top, salt, and dipped in chocolate. The...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkNew YorkBig Gay Ice Cream