Tina G.
4/26/2025
I honestly love Benny's Pizza. Their Grandma pie is hands down my favorite -- the crust is crispy, the sauce tastes super fresh, and the whole thing just hits every time. Everyone there is always...
Benny's Pizza
Closed
(11)
Photos
18 West Rd
Pleasant Valley, NY 12569
Benny's Pizza is dedicated to serving great food in a welcoming environment, with a focus on community across its locations. One of their establishments can be found in Cortland, NY, where customers can enjoy their signature pizza offerings.
With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, Benny's Pizza creates a casual dining experience for everyone. Whether dining in or ordering online, patrons can expect delicious meals made with care and attention to detail.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.011 reviewsScotty W.
8/16/2025
Tried Benny's Pizza and stromboli, for the first time and the last time. Pizza slice was larger than most other pizzeria's but sauce and cheese had zero flavor. The stromboli or should I say...
Ernie F.
12/30/2023
As there are many pizza places to check out, this is another one. Benny's is still new on the block, and progress is being made. The selections and toppings are endless with the pizza -- so far,...
P V.
10/22/2024
Stopped by randomly. Absolutely killer slices, I'll be honest the plaza and place look disappointing from the outside but once you walk in the place is spotless clean and their specialty slices...
Cj W.
5/14/2025
Food is normally pretty good but the last 3 chicken parm sandwiches I have ordered have been burnt to a crisp and it just falls apart. They use to not toast the bread at all, now it's burnt every...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.