Karena C.
5/24/2025
Best lobster roll we ate in montauk! We tried a few and this was the best in terms of freshness, flavor, and price. Store is locally owned and the owner Kimberly was super sweet they do a 2 for...
Bennett Shellfish
Open
(39)
Photos
2 S Debusy Rd
Montauk, NY 11954
Bennett Shellfish Montauk Est. 1600's. The Bennett's are one of the East End's founding families. They have been working/harvesting the local bays and ocean for over 14 generations. Specializing in daily, locally caught seafood. Our Clam Pie is a must-try! Our seafood is handled, monitored, and refrigerated under strict sanitary conditions. Your health and safety are our number one priority. All our products are grill and oven-ready, made fresh daily... Clam pies, Chowders, White Clam Sauce, Stuffed Clams, Stuffed Scallops, Fish Cakes, Crab Bites, Seafood Pockets, and amazing desserts! Try our daily made cakes and pies, specializing in birthday and wedding cakes!
Reviews
4.539 reviews
Danielle P.
6/24/2025
Finally had the chance to give Bennett Shellfish a try after seeing it all over social media. As others have said here and on the Gram, this is run out of a couple's actual home and as such, there...
Hanna F.
6/19/2025
The lobster rolls were very good but the service was so odd and unpleasant. We asked them if there was a beach they recommended to bring our food to eat and they rudely said we could figure it...
Greg F.
8/16/2025
Wow!!! On a daytrip to Montauk this week, we took advantage of Bennett Shellfish's amazing deal of 2 for $40 lobster rolls. The lobster was perfectly fresh, sweet and ample, and the price cannot...
Lakeisha S.
10/19/2024
Visited the Hamptons for the 1st time & my friends decided that we wanted lobster rolls. We were unsure about the entrance because we didn't know that it was a literal building that look like a...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.