Natasha T.
6/23/2019
Bagels your way is the right way to go!!!' Being a UPSer we surely burn a lot of energy and the appetite for tasty nutrition is a necessity to fuel the body..... Susie provided exceptional...
Bagels Your Way Cafe
$$
Closed
(28)
Photos
187 Middle Country Rd
Middle Island, NY 11953
Paul's Bagel Cafe is a local eatery in Middle Island, NY, offering a delightful selection of freshly baked pastries and hot bagels made in-house daily, accompanied by a cup of freshly brewed coffee to kickstart your morning. For lunch, they serve an array of mouthwatering sandwiches, homemade deli salads, and comforting hot soups. Committed to providing exceptional food and service, Paul's Bagel Cafe also offers catering services for parties and family gatherings.
With two convenient locations in Middle Island and Holbrook, Paul's Bagel Cafe is a go-to spot for locals craving the best bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich on Long Island, featuring two extra-large eggs, three strips of thick-cut bacon, and two slices of cheese on a fresh bagel or roll, served with a choice of coffee or orange juice. Whether you're looking for a satisfying breakfast or a delicious lunch, Paul's Bagel Cafe is the place to be.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.528 reviewsDiane M.
4/19/2025
My online order was completely messed up. They gave the nerve to charge so much for each extra topping on the bagel, but not add it to the bagel! Not even toasted like was requested...can't...
Chris G.
3/8/2025
Stopped by and had an excellent ham cheese and egg bagel! The service was excellent! Warm, friendly, and very helpful. The Bagel had just come out of the oven when I arrived and was delicious! I...
Mike F.
12/8/2024
Although the bagels at this store are fantastic. The clerk behind the counter is quite unconcerned about hygiene. He kept the same gloves on preparing my order after touching money and other items...
brad b.
11/26/2023
Staff and food/along w specials - make this place ONE OF MY GO~to's in the area. I just had breakfast here - it could not of been better and priced well. EVERYTHING WAS GREAT. So nice and so...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.