Howard R.
8/7/2025
Delicious bagels and scallion cream cheese. Having had some other bagels in a couple of other spots, there was no comparison to this place. JUST DELICIOUS BAGELS!!!
Bagels & Co
$
Closed
(151)
Photos
391 Amsterdam Ave
New York, NY 10024
Bagels & Co is a local deli in New York City that prides itself on using fresh, local ingredients to create their delicious bagels. With a focus on simplicity, quality, and tradition, their family-friendly atmosphere and intimate charm make it a welcoming spot for guests.
With two convenient locations on Amsterdam Ave and York Ave, Bagels & Co offers a taste of their perfected bagels to residents and visitors alike. Their dedication to using only the best ingredients ensures that every bite is a flavorful experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.5151 reviews
Geoffrey B.
7/28/2025
I ordered two bagels and unfortunately, one of the bagels was completely incorrect (which I didn't realize until getting home). Normally I can roll with a mistaken bagel order, but in this case I...
Alisa J.
8/18/2025
Bagel was good and surprisingly the salmon was very fresh. Wish they put capers on it. Was overall a good sandwich and liked it a lot. Service was pretty quick.
Macarena O.
4/12/2025
Very standard bagel place. I got the everything with scallion spread and added tomato. The staff were fast on preparing the bagels and the price is what you expect ($5ish). Its nice that they...
Gary R.
3/6/2025
They were open at 5:00 am so earlier than most bagel places. These are real NY bagels and are unique to the area. Every time in NYC I have to grab real bagels. The service was great order at the...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.