Howard R.
8/7/2025
Delicious bagels and scallion cream cheese. Having had some other bagels in a couple of other spots, there was no comparison to this place. JUST DELICIOUS BAGELS!!!
Bagels & Co
$
Closed
(151)
Photos
391 Amsterdam Ave
New York, NY 10024
Bagels & Co is a local deli in New York City that prides itself on using fresh, local ingredients to create their delicious bagels. With a focus on simplicity, quality, and tradition, their family-friendly atmosphere and intimate charm make it a welcoming spot for guests.
With two convenient locations on Amsterdam Ave and York Ave, Bagels & Co offers a taste of their perfected bagels to residents and visitors alike. Their dedication to using only the best ingredients ensures that every bite is a flavorful experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.5151 reviews
Geoffrey B.
7/28/2025
I ordered two bagels and unfortunately, one of the bagels was completely incorrect (which I didn't realize until getting home). Normally I can roll with a mistaken bagel order, but in this case I...
Alisa J.
8/18/2025
Bagel was good and surprisingly the salmon was very fresh. Wish they put capers on it. Was overall a good sandwich and liked it a lot. Service was pretty quick.
Alexa K.
10/19/2025
Huge, delicious, and very appropriately seasoned everything bagels! So many cream cheese options, and really friendly staff! The price is similar to most places in New York. The only thing I can...
Macarena O.
4/12/2025
Very standard bagel place. I got the everything with scallion spread and added tomato. The staff were fast on preparing the bagels and the price is what you expect ($5ish). Its nice that they...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.