Elisa R.
12/22/2024
Even though you forgot my salt pepper ketchup The rye bagel was phenomenal ! One egg w cheese The place needs a little updating Never came here before and a local! Bagel sandwich w a hot drink...
Bagels by the Bay
Closed
(16)
Photos
1380 Montauk Hwy
Oakdale, NY 11769
Bagels by the Bay, also known as Bagel Doctor, is a popular bagel shop located in Oakdale, NY, known for its good food and exceptional service. The staff creates a welcoming atmosphere, making dining experiences enjoyable for visitors.
With an appealing selection of bagels and coffee, including unique flavors such as white chocolate raspberry creamer, customers have praised the quality and affordability of their offerings. This charming establishment is a favorite local spot for those seeking a satisfying and delicious meal.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.016 reviews
Phil S.
9/27/2025
Great service but the food is awful. Terrible bagels. Bland and tasteless BEC. Better off traveling an extra 10-15 min to get something with some actual good.
Stephanie K.
8/22/2024
Ordered a mini well done egg bagel, none of the bagels were crispy or well done. Was not worth eating, threw half away. Price was fair. Dining room has tables for patrons that want to dine...
Matthew C.
6/28/2024
I don't understand the low-star ratings on Yelp. I have been going to this place for years and I've never had an issue with the food, pricing or service. The bagels are delicious: large, crusty,...
D C.
7/29/2024
Outstanding sausage, egg and cheese bagel sandwich. Friendly staff. Very convenient opening hours.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.