Jimmy M.
10/18/2025
The owners are nice and friendly. The bagels here are great and the sandwich's are ginormous. The sandwich could easily be for 2 meals for around 14 dollars. The bagel had steak egg and cheese and...
Bagels by the Bay
$
Open
(58)
Photos
1235 Bay St
Staten Island, NY 10305
Bagels By the Bay is a beloved Staten Island establishment known for its traditional, kettle-boiled bagels made from the finest ingredients. Each bagel is crafted with care and baked on-site, ensuring a fresh and satisfying experience for every customer.
In addition to bagels, the menu features a variety of options, including pastries, salads, and wraps, all designed to cater to a range of tastes. The commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in their no-fee direct ordering and delivery service.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.558 reviews
Lauren M.
6/2/2025
This spot on Bay Street is a solid spot for a bagel any day. They have a larger menu than I expected, so I definitely need to go back to try some more. There's limited seating inside, but the shop...
Tracey S.
11/21/2025
Bagels on the Bay makes the BEST sandwich on Staten Island. They are huge and served on super fresh poppy seed rolls. They use the freshest ingredients and are super nice and helpful. My...
Sarah C.
7/26/2025
Came on vacation and we loved this bagel shop. We ate in one day and took to go another day. The bagels were tasty and the gentlemen behind the counter were helpful and very kind to us. We loved...
Santiago C.
3/20/2025
Great Bagels. Can't go wrong. The staff owners are amazing. Very nice no matter what time you show up.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.