Steph Q.
11/1/2025
My family and I spent a few days in Islip and tried several bagel shops in the area. We came across Bagels and More and had a positive first experience. It ended up becoming our go-to spot for egg...
Bagels and More
$
Open
(18)
Photos
167 Islip Ave
Islip, NY 11751
Bagels and More is a compact eatery located in New York, specializing in bagels. While they do not make their own bagels on-site, they bring in their products from another source. This establishment offers customers an alternative option for enjoying bagels in a convenient setting.
In addition to bagels, Bagels and More provides a casual atmosphere for patrons looking for a quick bite. The focus remains on providing a selection of bagels, despite not being a traditional New York bagel shop. This makes it a convenient stop for those seeking to satisfy their bagel cravings.
Generated from the web
Also at this address
Reviews
3.518 reviews
Demishia O.
6/18/2025
I moved so I decided to try this bagel shop. For a Saturday it was not very busy. I ordered turkey bacon sandwich with eggs and cheese. The sandwich was good, but the bagel could have been softer....
Cheyenne M.
3/14/2024
the egg salad on a roll from here is my favorite. order one you won't regret it. i'm craving one right now!!!
Rohan B.
10/23/2023
The food was good but my order was complete wrong. Which is weird since the guy confirmed to me what the order would be.
Keith F.
1/7/2024
This is a small family run bagel shop. If you like that mom and pops feeling you will love this place. It is a mom and son team and they always are attentive when you arrive and provide good,...
See a problem?
