Geri K.
9/8/2024
We try to return to the area for the bagels from the store. They are made fresh daily. The store is clean Bagels, like many other things is a matter of taste. So, we always place an order for...
Bagelry
$
Closed
(25)
Photos
507 Central Ave
Cedarhurst, NY 11516
Bagelry in Cedarhurst, NY is a beloved bagel shop owned and operated by a local family. They take pride in crafting fresh bagels daily and creating homemade cream cheeses on the premises.
Locals and out-of-towners alike rave about the signature tuna salad offered at Bagelry, making it a must-try dish for visitors seeking a taste of the area's culinary delights.
Generated from their available business information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.525 reviews
Ciara H.
3/28/2025
Love this small shop! The staff is friendly, they make egg-cellent egg salad(salt and pepper upon request) and the coffee is tasty as well!
Sunita P.
8/18/2025
terrible service ! the Indian lady in this store is very mean and always has a attitude ! she charges what ever she wants to charge that day . todays price was$8 for a plain croissant with cheese....
Nicki G.
1/5/2023
I think I got a total of 5 bagels at this place during my 4 day stay in cedarhurst. These bagels were so delicious and I loved both the veggie and the scallion cream cheese. The man, maybe the...
Meyas B.
6/30/2024
not what they used to be. I'm sure this place has changed hands since Cedarhurst and the five towns has changed dramatically over the last several years. The bagels were doughy and became very...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.