Paul B.
12/31/2023
I went here quite by accident - but it was a great mistake...! The staff was extremely friendly and helpful. And the bagels are terrific! Nicely sized yet soft and easy to eat. Too many places...
Bagelicious Cafe
$$
Closed
(66)
Photos
1031 Route 112
Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Bagelicious Cafe, located in Port Jefferson Station, NY, offers a diverse menu featuring a variety of breakfast and lunch options, including French toast, pancakes, bagels, and paninis. The cafe prides itself on using fresh ingredients to create delicious meals, catering to both traditional tastes and modern preferences.
Guests can enjoy classic items such as the Old Fashioned French Toast and Triple Grilled Cheese, as well as specialty wraps like the Caesar Wrap and South of the Border Wrap. With a focus on quality and customer satisfaction, Bagelicious Cafe is a go-to spot for a satisfying meal in a casual setting.
Generated from the website
Reviews
2.566 reviewsSilent V.
11/7/2025
OMMFG...what a dumpster fire this place is. Stopped in at 7am this morning, 11/7, for breakfast. Ordered one fried egg on a roll SPK, and two Italian Jelly Cookies. I even pointed directly to...
Taylor L.
8/10/2025
Very distasteful bagel store. Paid $38 for 3 egg sandwiches with ONE slice of bacon on top of everything being cooked incorrectly
keith ..
9/16/2025
I never write reviews. This is the fourth time I've come into this store. Everytime I've come in there's been issues with my orders. It's one thing to make a mistake and apologize for it during a...
Bill C.
6/28/2025
This is the second time I have come to this place and disappointed both times. Bagel is below average and they are really a little crazy with their prices. Overpriced for below average....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.