Arthur A.
6/2/2025
Given my location, the overall taste, and the value, I'd say this is my favorite bagel place in Fort Hamilton. Service is usually quick, though at the usual busy times there can be a bit of a...
Bagel Supreme
$
Closed
(83)
Photos
9401 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11209
Bagel Supreme is a cozy neighborhood spot in Brooklyn, NY that specializes in crafting delicious bagels and breakfast sandwiches.
With a focus on quality ingredients and friendly service, Bagel Supreme aims to provide a satisfying and convenient dining experience for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.583 reviewsSalvador A.
7/29/2025
I ordered a sandwich and a banana smoothie from Bagel Supreme. When the order arrived, the smoothie was missing. I asked the delivery lady about it, but she couldn't speak English, so I called the...
Erik A.
5/1/2025
FOOD POISONING second time in 2 months after eating the bacon in a sandwich. Idk if it's the pork or contaminated uncleaned utensils used with again with cooked food. It's a shame It happened...
Ed P.
9/24/2024
The bagel was nice, no complaints there. But paying was fairly easy UNTIL I went to my banks website and found they charged me $10.82 even though my receipt said $10.50. I don't know why there was...
Cindy C.
7/24/2023
Great little spot for a quick and yummy breakfast. Staff is always friendly and orders come out in a timely manner. My favorite is a toasted sesame bagel with lox spread but we've also tried their...
See a problem?
