Stacey S.
10/5/2025
10/4/25. Good pumpkin coffee, rugelah (esp the chocolate, and yes $20/pound), cinnamon muffin and bagels. Filings remain skimpy.
Bagel Plaza
$
Closed
(94)
Photos
1704 Merrick Rd
Merrick, NY 11566
Bagel Plaza is the oldest bagel place on the south shore, serving up all original recipes and sandwiches made from scratch to the residents of Merrick, NY.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.094 reviews
Jackie O.
9/28/2024
Quick service and very friendly Clean and everything looks fresh! I ordered a whole wheat everything thinking the everything seeds were inside the bagel too (I saw this on a prior Yelp post)......
Alex M.
10/19/2025
We had Bagel Plaza cater my daughter's baby naming ceremony today and the food and service was outstanding! We worked with the owners Sam and Yanna and were able to get everything we wanted for a...
Bobby Q.
9/28/2025
Flagel hard and very chewy, doesn't seem fresh. They forget items frequently when ordering delivery. HIGH priced. Place really declined with quality.
Dana U.
12/6/2024
I've been a loyal customer of Bagel Plaza since childhood. As a Muslim who only eats Halal, I've always felt safe eating here because Kosher food aligns closely with our dietary needs--it's very...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.