Colette G.
7/28/2025
5 star bagels with 3 star service. NOBODY makes bagels as big & fluffy as Bagel Lady. We are hooked, for over 20 years. THIS is our bagel place. But JUST bagels is all we patronize them for. We...
Bagel Lady Cafe
$
Open
(59)
Photos
99 Route 25A
Shoreham, NY 11786
Bagel Lady Cafe is a cozy eatery in Shoreham, NY that specializes in serving freshly baked bagels and a variety of breakfast and lunch options.
With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, customers can enjoy a casual dining experience and indulge in delicious bagel creations made to order.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
2.559 reviews
Joseph M.
4/17/2025
I grew up in Shoreham, worked for a decade at the Rocky Point Italian Bakery making Italian bread and I can honestly say these bagels are second to none, especially in the TOB. The owner has grown...
Rick C.
1/27/2025
Update: Decided to give this place another chance. Still not great. Average egg sandwich at best. Take a drive to Fresh & Hot Bagels in RP. Best place around and it's not particularly close.
Isabella S.
6/7/2025
Always fresh food served with a kind smile!! Best bagels in Long Island, my boyfriend and I come from San Diego just for these bagels !!
Patricia M.
5/29/2025
Best bagels You can call ahead for pickup and skip waiting on line . Sunday morning gets pretty busy
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.