Katarina L.
11/5/2025
Cute little bagel shop right on the main ave with a great selection, friendly team and delicious bagels. They were the perfect stop the morning after a wedding in town, and the only thing our...
Bagel-ish
Closed
(29)
Photos
226 Main St
Beacon, NY 12508
Bagel-ish is a unique bagel shop located in Beacon, NY, known for its artisan, all-natural, gut-friendly bagels crafted with specially milled flour and a meticulous production process. The shop not only serves delicious bagels but also acts as a training center for aspiring bagel entrepreneurs, fostering a community that values health-conscious and flavorful offerings.
Founded by Beth George, who has a rich background in bagel innovation and business consulting, Bagel-ish continues the legacy of its late co-founder Frank Mauro. The shop emphasizes traditional techniques and locally sourced ingredients, creating a diverse menu that includes unique toppings and sandwiches designed to delight customers' taste buds.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.029 reviews
Whitney L.
10/29/2025
You ever have a bagel so good that you had to go back for a second bagel? Well, I've never had to do that UNTIL I tried the rosemary & extra virgin olive oil bagel with fresh scallion & garlic...
Melissa G.
8/11/2025
These bagels are fantastic! I came on a Sunday, and the store was almost entirely sold out. My friend bought the last three cheese bagels and I got a bag of six plain mini bagels. I live in...
Christine L.
5/9/2025
I love sourdough bagels and the storefront was so cute so I tried a Za'tar Evoo bagel- it was so good! Soft and fresh, and the seasoning was incredible. Didn't get cream cheese, and it didn't need...
Nicole A.
6/22/2025
Can I leave 10 stars? Let me just say it upfront - Bagelish is absolutely unhinged in the best possible way. This place has completely redefined what I thought I knew about bagels, and I'm...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.