My go to bagel place, delish! Today, it seems as if we got day old (or more) bagels. I was looking forward to their usual excellence but was very disappointed.
Bagel Cafe
(41)
Photos
Bagel Cafe is a local eatery with two convenient locations in Middle Island and Holbrook, NY.
They offer a wide variety of freshly baked bagels and other breakfast items, as well as catering services for special events.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews

bagels are fine nothing special. service sucks tho. the young lady at the counter with dirty blonde hair and lashes that are way too long for her eye shape was very rude. she told me that they...
Food is good. Service is absolutely terrible. I live close so I've tried numerous times but they get my order wrong EVERY SINGLE TIME. it's a BEC on a roll, a very simple order, you are a bagel...
Placed an order and when I questioned why I was being charged al-a-cart the cashier Ella responded with a breakdown of each item. When I corrected her she caught an attitude and told the manager...
Just visited the Bagel Cafe today and had a wonderful experience! Great egg sandwich on a bagel...really nice fresh hot coffee....pleasant eating area...and really friendly and helpful staff....
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.