Mathew M.
9/11/2025
I order bagel's here for breakfast practically daily. They have been consistent every day for years. The people that work there are kind and happy people. The bagels are great, and the...
Bagel Boys
$
Closed
(40)
Photos
48 Germonds Rd
New City, NY 10956
Bagel Boys New City in New City, NY is a popular bagel and pastry shop offering a wide selection of Boars Head deli products.
Customers can place large orders by calling ahead, making it convenient for gatherings or events.
Generated from their available business information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.040 reviews
Daisy C.
12/25/2024
I'm a bit of a bagel snob so ignore this review if you'll eat any bagel. These bagels are very doughy in my opinion. I love a good "anything" bagel but these have way too much salt. The egg and...
Chris B.
5/12/2025
The best bagels in Rockland County! Fresh bagels every day! This is your one stop shop! Excellent menu and service!! They always prepare my food right away and I am never late to work. Love this...
Leslie S.
5/12/2025
Trying to think of something good to say is a struggle. Bagels are chewy. And also once I asked for an iced tea and instead of sugar, they put SALT. Nice selection of drinks, candy, salads. Pretty...
Stephen S.
6/10/2023
The bagels at Bagel Boys are perfection. They are not overly thick like some other places so when cut fit into a toaster without problem. The ratio of crust to the inside is right. A bagel should...
See a problem?
