J L.
10/7/2025
Beautiful looking place, did not eat the food because the holes and the bagels were so big. I felt my food would fall through the holes. So I moved onto everything bagel whose bagel looked twice...
Bagel Basket Cafe
$
Open
(120)
Photos
639 Commack Rd
Commack, NY 11725
Bagel Basket Cafe is a cozy eatery in Smithtown, Town of, NY, known for serving freshly baked bagels and a variety of breakfast and lunch options.
With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, this cafe is a popular spot for locals and visitors looking for a casual dining experience.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.0120 reviewsKenneth S.
8/4/2025
This used to be a very solid place for early morning bagel or more robust lunch with salads and açaí. Still serve the same fare but quality and service have decreased significantly while prices...
Alexa D.
1/17/2025
Always good food at decent prices don't forget to get the coffee it's fresh an yummy
Henry S.
1/22/2025
This place is solid. He hungryman is good and also the paninis are not bad. The chicken was not dry like most panini sandwiches.
Rach C.
7/4/2024
Officially, I'm never going back. I've been going to Bagel Basket for YEARS out of convenience. Today, however, sealed the deal. I paid $30 for a breakfast wrap & a turkey hero for my long work...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.