Mark D.
9/23/2023
We hit up this place on move-in day at SUNY Geneseo on a whim. Definitely was not disappointed in the quality of the sub. I ordered the Italian Assorted Sub and it was great. The meat combination...
Aunt Cookies Sub Shop
$
Open
(75)
Photos
76 Main St
Geneseo, NY 14454
Aunt Cookies Sub Shop is a popular eatery located on Main Street in Geneseo, NY, offering a delectable selection of sub sandwiches.
With a convenient online ordering system, customers can easily customize their orders and have them prepared for pick-up at their preferred time.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.075 reviews
Amanda C.
12/8/2023
This place is a local legend. I had the occasion to try it finally and I can see why. Friendly service, generous portions, reasonable wait time. I ordered a steak sub that was prepared just right...
Reema M.
9/5/2022
We stopped at Aunt Cookies sub shop for a quick bite during our travel. The place was really busy but Kat at the counter patiently took our order and also helped set up a table for us based on our...
Christina M.
5/20/2023
I'm sort of a sub snob and have to say, this was a WOW!!! Came highly recommended to my team and I who were working downtown in Geneseo for the day. The small Cookie that came with it was a nice...
Scott W.
7/29/2022
At the advice of friends, we stopped here to pickup lunch for a picnic in Letchworth State Park. This unassuming shop has great sandwiches on the BEST breads. We had our subs on Italian bread...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.