Michael P.
11/4/2025
Excellent food & service for a pickup order Boston baked scallops are the BEST AROUND!!
Atlantic Seafood
$$
Open
(56)
Photos
69 E Genesee St
Baldwinsville, NY 13027
Atlantic Seafood Co has been serving the community of Baldwinsville, NY for over 45 years, offering guests the freshest and highest quality seafood in a warm and welcoming family-run atmosphere. Specializing in Original or Boston Baked Haddock or Scallops, their menu also includes homemade salads, shrimp, scallops, clams, and a delectable baked mac and cheese made from scratch with aged sharp cheddar.
With a commitment to freshness and quality, Atlantic Seafood Co is a go-to destination for seafood lovers in Baldwinsville, providing a diverse menu of delicious options and a friendly dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.556 reviews
Jorge V.
9/23/2025
Orders are accepted over the phone which makes food pick up easy. 'Employees are friendly. Haddock is most popular, available baked (2 styles- baked original and Boston baked) or fried. All three...
Erica O.
11/25/2024
My husband wanted fried fish but I didn't want my fish fried. Perfect option was Atlantic Seafood because they sell both. I've purchased their raw haddock by the pound before but this time I...
Christine B.
4/13/2025
Best seafood restaurant in bville. If you can order ahead- do that (esp on Friday's) before 3. Also if you are craving mac and cheese go here. It's delicious.
Lashonna L.
7/18/2025
Food is great, customer service is great, and ambience is enjoyable. Usually pretty crowded on Fridays but the line moves swiftly.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.