Niki K.
5/26/2025
My #1 Stop Every Time I Land in New York! I've been going to Atlantic Pizza for over 20 years, and let me tell you--this place is legendary. I live in Orange County, California now, but every...
Atlantic Pizzeria & Restaurant
$$
Closed
(82)
Photos
171 Atlantic Ave
Freeport, NY 11520
Teresa and Rocco Napoli bought Atlantic Pizzeria in 1988, a few years after they returned to Long Island from a decade-long sojourn in their ancestral home, the Calabrian town of Marina di Gioiosa Jonica. Twenty years later, their son Frank runs the store, and his primary responsibility is to support and build upon his mother's artistry.When you choose to have a meal at the Atlantic Pizzeria, you'll enjoy more than just a good slice of pie - you'll enjoy a unique experience with a vivid atmosphere that will leave you going back for seconds.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.582 reviews
Andrew L.
7/28/2025
If you truly want good pizza, this is the place. No need for fancy specialty slices (although they all look amazing). If you want the best regular slice of pizza, you need to try this. Crispy thin...
Imogen C.
7/7/2025
Whatever you indulge in, make sure you get a plain cheese slice too! Specialty slices are off the hook but their plain cheese slice.... Now that is how you know it's good pizza! Best Pizza on Long...
Louis S.
6/22/2025
Best pizza and sausage rolls on Long Island! Every time I'm in NY I always make sure I eat a lot of pizza, and this trip I came to this pizzeria at least 5 times. Their sausage roll is beyond...
Tom N.
4/5/2025
Really warm atmosphere and staff, amazing deli/restaurant counter in addition to delicious pizza. Neighborhood staple for 5 decades. Was my first stop in with the fam, great place to go for lunch.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.