Chuck P.
6/9/2025
Eat their food and you can see how much they care about their ingredients. It's a homerun sandwich place. They use top notch ingredients. To compete in this sandwich market is tough but this place...
Anthony's Paninoteca
$
Closed
(21)
Photos
3994 Amboy Rd
Staten Island, NY 10308
Anthony's Paninoteca is a cherished Italian eatery nestled in Staten Island, NY. This family-owned establishment prides itself on offering delectable sandwiches and salads, prepared with the utmost care and using only the freshest ingredients. Each item on the menu is crafted daily to ensure a delightful culinary experience for every visitor.
Known for their authentic Italian sandwiches, Anthony's Paninoteca has garnered a loyal following of patrons who appreciate the dedication to quality showcased in every bite. Customers rave about the generous portions and flavorful combinations, with many declaring it as one of the best sandwich spots in the area.
Generated from the website content
Reviews
4.521 reviews
Renee I.
8/6/2024
We're so glad we stopped by after visiting the cemetery. I highly recommend the #13 Maria, Staten Island Italy a la vodka and the Phil Leonardo. Other family members ordered their build your own...
Ann T.
4/4/2025
Anthony's may not be known for pizza BUT he makes a sfincione pizza. Its crispy airy crust is smeared with a savory sauce of onions, tomatoes, and oregano and then topped with grated cheese and...
Michelina B.
6/11/2025
Today we ordered sandwiches, 4 in total. One cold: the Luigi; and three hot: the Gino, the Joey Muscle and the special of a Ruben pastrami (on a hero). It was for a pick up and the total order...
Steve M.
12/5/2024
We came in to try the porchetta which is a must to have. Pork , broccoli rabe , fresh mozzarella and pecorino crema. We moved from SI to TN last year, my wife follows his sandwich making FB...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.