Angelo's Pizza

Closed

(752)

Call

Website

Photos

1697 Broadway

New York, NY 10019

+1 (212) 245-8811

https://www.angelosbroadway.com

Angelo's Pizza is a 4th generation pizza-making family dynasty that starts with the original Angelo, who humbly came to this country in the late 1930s. Settling in New York City, he worked a lifetime making great and authentic Italian Pizza, first at various pizza shops around the city, and then at his own store, the legendary Pizza Chef, on Brooklyn’s Fulton Street. Angelo only made pizza with coal ovens, typically running between 800°-1,000° F, producing crisp pies with a nice char within 60-90 seconds. As time passed, Angelo felt there were only a handful of pizza places left in the city like his and vowed to continue making traditional New York Style Coal-Oven Pizza. Angelo’s passion has been passed down for family generations, as his children and nephews continue his traditions of excellent pizza making at Angelo’s Pizza on Broadway.

The best coal-fired pizza in NYC!

Also at this address

Paa Research

Keyboard Instrument Rentals

The Late Show with Stephen Colbert

163 reviews

Natas

Find related places

Restaurants

Reviews

3.5752 reviews

Carmen T.

9/11/2025

Eggplant and pasta was delicious! We were told they made their own pasta. All five of us had a very tasty lunch. Service was excellent.

Read more on Yelp

Scott K.

8/28/2025

Five stars: Great I might be biased because I was starving after traveling 7-8 hours, but the food here was delicious. We got into NYC around 10 PM, so many places were closed. One of the...

Read more on Yelp

Sarah C.

8/10/2025

a pretty casual restaurant that seems pretty traditional. there's free bread and olive oil for starters. we tried the: - 17" old fashioned margherita ($26) with mushrooms (+$3.95) and sausage...

Read more on Yelp

Jonathan R.

6/13/2025

Right next to The Tonight Show. There are a couple of "Angelo's Coal Fire Pizza's" in the area, mostly the same menu. This location has more seating up straits so requesting seating upstairs to...

Read more on Yelp

Jens J.

5/15/2025

A convenient Midtown stop for great Italian food. With a traditional-feeling atmosphere Angelo's has a larger seating area upstairs than downstairs. Located next to the studio where the...

Read more on Yelp

Owner verified

See a problem?

Italian restaurant, Eating places

Serafina Broadway

Serafina Broadway is a restaurant that provides a range of casual dining options. It features Murano-glass, hand-painted ceilings, shimmering murals and mosaic tile pizza oven. The restaurant serves a variety of Italian cuisine and seafood items. Its menu includes appetizers, pizzas, entrees, pasta dishes and desserts. The restaurant additionally serves porcini mushrooms, caviar, truffles, buffalo mozzarellas, and grilled meat and fish dishes. It offers online reservation and takeout services. The restaurant also features a bar and lounge, as well as a dining area that can accommodate up to 110 guests. Serafina Broadway is a part of Serafina Restaurant Group, which operates several food establishments throughout New York.