Dee C.
9/23/2025
Awesome store. I have found treasures. One big downfall is only 3 filling rooms!!! You spend half the time in a line. Please add more
American Thrift Store
Closed
(19)
Photos
2280 N Ocean Ave Unit G
Farmingville, NY 11738
American Thrift - Farmingville is a local thrift store situated in Farmingville, NY. The store offers a variety of second-hand items for sale at affordable prices.
Customers can browse through a selection of clothing, household goods, and other miscellaneous items at American Thrift - Farmingville, providing a budget-friendly shopping experience for those in the community.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.519 reviews
Monica D.
7/21/2025
This place was great when it first opened, but I guess that was just to win us over. Pricing is inconsistent and often high for a thrift store. The following was my experience today... ME:...
Cat C.
1/18/2025
One of the few thrift stores we hit when we're in Eastern LI. Bright airy store. Not my favorite setup because they sort clothing by color, not by size. Large selection of clothing. A lot of other...
Laurie T.
2/27/2025
Brianna was a amazing sales clerk. She was so very helpful. The store is clean and very we'll stocked great prices
William H.
4/3/2024
They charge you a 25 cent service fee that you don't know about until you pay at the register. What is that? How is that legal? And as per long island thrift stores, selection is sparse and prices...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.