BW W.
6/5/2025
Best Pizza in the Hamptons by far you want thin and crispy NY pizza this is the spot not thick and soggy like the Rest once your out east . Pie is always Good forget the negative reviews
American Pie Pizzeria
$
Closed
(91)
Photos
2044 Montauk Hwy
Bridgehampton, NY 11932
American Pie Pizzeria in Bridgehampton, NY, emphasizes inclusivity and accessibility within their dining experience. The establishment caters to a diverse clientele, offering a variety of menu options to please every palate.
With a focus on quality and customer satisfaction, American Pie Pizzeria aims to create a welcoming atmosphere for all visitors. Their commitment to exceptional service and delicious food is evident in their attention to detail.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.591 reviews
S A.
8/24/2025
Here I am again giving it another chance. Ordered a cheese slice and it was just meh. No sauce just a hint of red food coloring that gives the appearance of sauce topped with cheese. Again, had to...
Dizzy G.
10/27/2024
The pizza here is extremely sub par and does not at all taste like NY pizza. It also ALWAYS comes completely burnt to BLACK on the bottom which tastes awful! The cheese does not want to stay on...
Luke L.
9/6/2024
Called ahead order was 2x the time estimated. I ordered a calzone with pepperoni and rather than make a fresh one they cut open a pre-cooked one and shoved a ton of pepperoni inside. Paid for 3...
Kali S.
8/16/2024
One of the best pizza places in the Hamptons and the best pizza slice by far. The food is great (their chicken parm slice is great) and the owner is extremely kind and the service is great! Will...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.