Charles M.
9/22/2025
Pizza, the way (imho) it should be; thin, tasty and when you think you're full, you have to have another piece. Workout tomorrow. The only pizza in Rochester we would serve to our friends from...
All Star Pizza
$
Closed
(72)
Photos
1628 Penfield Rd
Rochester, NY 14625
All Star Pizza is a family owned and operated pizzeria in Rochester NY. We are specialized in New York Style Thin Crust Pizza delivery and takeout. We also offer chicken wings, subs, Boneless Wings, salads, Wraps etc. Order your food now!
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.572 reviews
Ryley R.
8/30/2025
Nicest pizza guys I've ever encountered. Extremely friendly and professional. Incredible pizza, and I'm picky. Super quick service, convenient location and easy parking. Nice part of town. Cannot...
Lydia M.
2/4/2024
Pizza was okay. I really liked the thin crust, but I felt like the pizza itself didn't have a lot of taste. My family got a basic pizza with half broccoli and half pepperoni. The inside is...
Kimberly A.
5/17/2024
Tried All Star pizza tonight for the first time, it was just ok. We got cheese and pepperoni. I am a huge fan of thin crust so was really excited, however it was very bland. Didn't hate it, but...
Brooke G.
1/2/2024
Ordered pizza for NYE and picked it up. Pizza and wings were GREAT. very nice ppl and food was very tasty . Will be back for sure !!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.