All Star Cafe & Pizza

Permanently closed
tripadvisor logo

(4)

Call
Website
694 Arthur Kill Rd
Staten Island, NY 10308
+1 (718) 227-2000
http://www.allstarcafenyc.com
Order your favorite pizza, pasta, salad, wings and more with All Star Pizza located at 694 Arthur Kill Rd in Staten Island, NY. All Star Pizza is accepting orders online for delivery and takeout. To begin your order simply click on any menu category. Enjoy!

Also at this address

Reviews

tripadvisor logo
2.54 reviews
Photo of FrankSinatra143
Worst pizza
2/9/2022

What a disgrace to serve horrible pizza like that! Never again! My pizza was stale and the crust w...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Photo of Alan B
A good take-out dinner after a long day
12/13/2015

After a long and somewhat arduous day, we wanted to bring in dinner, and had enjoyed food from All S...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Photo of NJbrooklyn
Friday Nite Pizza Nite
11/14/2015

The Pizza & Calzone were Horrible. Avoid this place. Expensive and so not worth it. Ripoff. Nasty. N...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Pronto Pizza Pasta
Eating places, Cafe, Italian restaurant

Pronto Pizza Pasta

70
•
$$
"* This review is on their regular and Sicilian pies, as well as their service. To this day, this is the best pizza on Staten Island. When I say "pizza," I mean REAL pizza, and not that terrible..."
photo of Steve M.
Nonna's Pizzeria
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Nonna's Pizzeria

220
•
$
"Those who "Know me", they know 2 things. One, is I've been a Chef for many years. Two, is that I'm a big time "Pizza Snob". So, this place went "Viral" when they first opened. Talk about..."
photo of Joe M.
Mimmo's Brick Oven and Trattoria
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Carry-out only (except pizza) restaurant

Mimmo's Brick Oven and Trattoria

261
•
$$
"Absolutely delicious! Visiting from California and pulled up Yelp for a food spot to eat lunch in Staten Island and this place came up. As soon as I saw the photos of their food, I was sold...."
photo of Brookie L.
United States›New York›Staten Island›All Star Cafe & Pizza

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.