Zack G.
9/30/2025
Great corned beef sandwich. Solid pizza, solid black & white cookie. Nice staff. Basic New York deli fare done well.
72nd Eatery
Open
(13)
Photos
261 Columbus Ave
New York, NY 10023
72nd Eatery, located at 261 Columbus Ave, New York, NY, offers a diverse range of delicious food options, prominently featuring an array of pizzas, gourmet sandwiches, and burgers. Known for its well-crafted flavors and hearty portions, this eatery caters to a variety of tastes, ensuring that every guest finds something to enjoy.
The menu boasts popular items such as the Grilled Chicken Tijuana, classic Tuna Melt, and specialty burgers like the Hickory BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger, delighting customers with every bite. Committed to quality, 72nd Eatery emphasizes fresh ingredients and a blend of culinary influences, making it a stand-out choice for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.513 reviews
Micaela B.
10/29/2024
Service is horrible! I very obviously ordered a lox omelette and they sent me three pieces of salmon in a container! When I called, the women who answered said I "was wrong" and denied any...
Amelia L.
2/15/2023
Emerging from the space formerly occupied by Columbus Gourmet Foods is 72nd Eatery which opened a coupe of weeks ago. This fast casual restaurant is owned by the same people. The interior has...
Ainsley E.
4/25/2024
Had a very nice southwest chicken salad and a black and white cookie at this deli! Very affordable lunch considering the prices elsewhere. Chicken salad was a bit basic; could have used some...
Amanda C.
7/29/2023
Friendly service, there is a bathroom, extensive menu. Seats on the inside and outside.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.