Rebekah H.
6/19/2025
This was our first time here and everything was amazing. I pies were great, the people are amazing and so nice, and the entire interior is just so homey it's wonderful. We came here after being...
Pie Town Pie
$
Open
(111)
Photos
5613 Highway 60
Pie Town, NM 87827
Pie-O-Neer Pies in Pie Town, NM offers a nostalgic experience where visitors are transported to a simpler time upon entering the front door. Known for their scratch baking and specialty pies, the establishment hosts the annual Pie Town Pie Fest every September, inviting guests to enjoy custom pies and engage in the art of pie-making.
With a focus on quality over speed, Pie-O-Neer Pies encourages patrons to savor the experience of conversation while indulging in their delicious pies. Whether stopping by for a slice or ordering a signature specialty pie to be shipped anywhere in the US, visitors can expect a warm, welcoming atmosphere and a taste of homemade goodness.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5111 reviews
Mark R.
6/14/2025
Everything I had hoped and more. Got there later in the day so some of the food and pie options were limited--but didn't matter because what they had was awesome. Chili with corn "bread" (was more...
Steve A.
9/1/2025
Planned a stop in Pie Town on our last day of vacation and was very disappointed. The food looked great but we left because there was absolutely zero customer service. When we walked in there was...
Taylor H.
3/22/2025
This is homemade food-not fast food and it was delicious! A simple tasty menu that changes daily. The service was quick and friendly, even when it got busy. A rustic country setting that was clean...
Shelly S.
8/12/2025
The pies and ice cream are really good. The cookies are amazing as well. Now for the bad news . Showed up on a Friday and the sign says they open at 10am. Waited outside for 30 minutes and the...
See a problem?
