Nancy ..
9/17/2025
Great food. The chicken salad is nice with lots of celery. Yum! Also got a brown derby cake which was fabulous and filled with fresh fruit. Best deli around
Yellow Cottage Deli & Bakery
$
Closed
(46)
Photos
345 US Highway 206
Branchville, NJ 07826
Yellow Cottage has been part of the Sussex County community for over 30 years. Fresh baked breads, cakes, cookies, pies and pastries are always plentiful at our shop. Celebration cakes made to order for weddings, birthdays, anniversaries and corporate events. Our Deli sandwiches are generous! Add chips, a beverage and dessert-one stop to satisfy any size appetite. New to Yellow Cottage: Our Taste of Italy gourmet food line-excellent pasta and sauce products that make a home cooked meal quick and easy.Stop by our shop-YOUR GONNA LOVE what we have in store!
Also at this address
Reviews
3.546 reviewsKay S.
9/3/2025
WORST DELI IN THE COUNTY. The way staff treat customers is downright rude and disrespectful. I had placed an order over the phone, and when I arrived to pick up the sandwiches I was told in...
Gab D.
12/17/2023
So bad!!! Disgusting roast beef on old dry bread. I got a rum ball that was pure sugar and waxy sugar chocolate that a kid wouldn't eat. Someone said this was the best in the area ---then how...
Keith K.
7/4/2024
Alert: New York City Prices have invaded Branchville. OMG. I've lived in Branchville for 32 years now and I was a regular customer of the Yellow Cottage for a long time but over the past 5-6...
David E.
8/31/2024
Just went in with my family to order some pastries we were the only three people in the store for over 5 mins. And not ont one employee acknowledge us greeted us got some dirty looks would not...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.