Woody P.
2/3/2021
Bonnie, Matt, and staff at Waretown Coin are honest and fair. They pay cash and are decent folks. Have been dealing with them for years and always extremely satisfied with transactions. Highly...
Waretown Stamp and Coin Shop
$$
Closed
(11)
Photos
542 Route 9
Waretown, NJ 08758
Waretown Stamp and Coin Shop has been a family-run business since 1954, founded by Joe, who transitioned from sheet metal work to the world of numismatics. Today, the shop continues to thrive under the stewardship of his son Matt, passing down a rich legacy and expertise through three generations.
Specializing in numismatics, the shop offers free verbal appraisals for coins and provides an opportunity for customers to learn about the value of their collections. Although the stamp market is less favorable currently, they remain open to examining collections brought in by customers.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.011 reviewsNick M.
10/14/2025
Cashing in some 90% silver coins, expect 1/3 of the current melt value. 80% Canadian, 72% Mexican, 50% great Britain...... don't bother. As for non precious metal coins, innovation dollars BU,...
Robert G.
11/26/2023
Grab Bags Are The Best Anywhere!!! I got lucky and ordered a $100 grab bag from Waretown, keep in mind I have low expectations when I order grab bags. When I received my grab bag was I ever...
Paul B.
12/22/2023
best place around , great place for coins and stamps, wonderful staff , prices are well with in range, if you want to start the hobby they the collectors books to start for any age collector
Giovanni M.
12/18/2018
I have a huge coin luggage case, loaded with pristine, rare silver coins, dollars, stamps, etc., from around the world... 1700s and on. I have no urgency to unload them, esp. here. I suppose...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.