Valley Shepherd Creamery

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(37)

Call
Website

Photos

50 Fairmount Rd
Long Valley, NJ 07853
+1 (908) 876-3200
http://valleyshepherd.com

Valley Shepherd Creamery, located in Long Valley, NJ, is a large operation that retains a cozy neighborhood business feel. Visitors can enjoy tours of the grounds, witnessing the four species of animals on site and observing the cheese-making process in the processing room.

The gift shop at Valley Shepherd Creamery offers a diverse selection of items, from cheeses and artisan butter to ravioli and ricotta salad, making it a destination where guests can easily spend an entire day exploring and indulging in high-quality dairy products. With over 25 years of experience, the owner is a seasoned expert in the craft of cheese-making, ensuring top-notch quality for all products.

Generated from their available business information

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.537 reviews
Photo of Louis G.
Louis G.
7/19/2025

We have been wanting to visit this cheese icon for many months and finally made the trip. Missy owner, Nick and Miranda were all exceptionally friendly and provided terrific customer service....

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Coburn S.
Coburn S.
12/29/2024

This is a cheese factory and creamery in the Fairmont, New Jersey area and is an excellent place to go if you're wanting quality cheeses and dairy products. I visited on a Saturday and it wasn't...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Matt P.
Matt P.
5/12/2025

We attended a Yelp Elite event at Beneduce farms which featured a stellar selection of cheese from Valley Shepherd. These paired excellently with their wine selection, hope for more collabs in the...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Jeff F.
Jeff F.
3/17/2024

Had a great experience at Valley Shepherd Creamery. We tired the goat milk yogurt for breakfast and then decided it was sooooo good, we needed to visit the store. The staff are super friendly and...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Maria M.
Maria M.
7/25/2023

Cheese and Sheep what more is there to life! What a place. The selection of cheeses are all great. Samples are usually available. The Soprano is my favorite. The sheep's milk yogurt is to die...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Cherry Grove Farm
Commercial and industrial building operation

Cherry Grove Farm

38
•
$$
"We all have a dream of a pastoral America, where we can indulge in products, made, or obtained right on the land in front of us. This is that place. This is a functioning dairy farm and also free..."
photo of Julia K.
Cheese, Fast food restaurants and stands, Services, nec, nec

Romi's Farm Product

2
"This is the absolute best yogurt on the market. It tastes like real homemade yogurt. Forget about the commercial yogurt in supermarkets,"
Old Hook Farm
Supermarkets, Inspection and testing services

Old Hook Farm

12
•
$$
"This place is heaven for pie lovers! Every pie we bought from them were fantastic! Now, this comes from someone who is not really a pie lover. Having lived in New England for many years, I..."
photo of Jules C.
United States›New Jersey›Long Valley›Valley Shepherd Creamery

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.