The Original Attilio's Pizza

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(122)

Photos

4057 Asbury Ave
Neptune, NJ 07712
The Original Attilio's Pizza, in Tinton Falls, NJ, serves up old school Italian cuisine. Nobody in the Jersey shore does Italian food like us. The Original Attilio's Pizza is a family owned restaurant that has been passed down from generation to generation. For over 40 years we have been a Jersey Shore tradition. Our full menu has so many options you won't know where to start. We have hot and cold subs, subs by the foot, calzones, Stromboli, wraps, soups, seafood, pasta, and of course delicious gourmet pizza. Our Special Sicilian pizza is one of our top favorites. We use the best Mozzarella (Grande Cheese) and keep the old world style of cooking real Italian comfort food. For a little Italian get away, you may come in and dine with us or place your order online and we can deliver to you (within a 3 mile radius). For that special occasion we have a private party room, catering options and we are BYOB friendly. Visit us today to taste why Attilio's means great Italian food to New Jersey residents. *Delivery is until 9:30pm *Dining room closes at 10pm *Take-out is until 11pm

Reviews

yelp logo
2.5122 reviews
Photo of Casey S.
Casey S.
9/3/2025

Stopped by Attilio's for a quick bite this weekend. Food: I had a plain slice, which was fine but didn't really have much personality or standout flavor. It's serviceable pizza, but nothing that...

Morgan M.
7/5/2025

The staff and the food here are amazing. I had a 40 person baby shower in my backyard I had catered with Local Smoke, they never showed up with the food.. after 2 hours of trying to get an answer...

Photo of George T.
George T.
2/23/2025

Garbage pizza ! Burnt, flavorless cold, crap! 1 1/2 hours for delivery - never again.

Photo of Thomas K.
Thomas K.
1/5/2025

attilio's was good. i had some penne vodka it was good nothing special. i also had pizza with sausage, peppers and onions. it was very good. could have used a little extra meat. the people were...

Photo of Brendalynne F.
Brendalynne F.
7/15/2023

Had a small (6") chicken parm sandwich here while I waited for my friends to meet me at the brewery next door. The chicken was thickly cut and very filling and the seasoning was good, but nothing...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew JerseyNeptuneThe Original Attilio's Pizza

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.