Joe K.
10/6/2025
Always fresh, everything on the menu is outstanding. This place is a must try, love the cinnamon rolls and pies!
The Magpie Bakery
$
Closed
(42)
Photos
2 Riverside Sq Ste 14
Bloomingdale, NJ 07403
Magpie Bakery in Bloomingdale, NJ, offers a delectable array of sweet and savory treats in various sizes. Indulge in their artisanal pies like Blueberry, Strawberry Rhubarb, and Coconut Custard, available in both medium and family sizes. For a savory delight, try their Chicken Pot Pie, Pulled Pork Pie, or Mac & Cheese Pie.
As North Jersey's go-to spot for custom cakes, Magpie Bakery is committed to delivering freshly baked, artisanal perfection in every bite. Their menu also features handpies such as Chicken Pot Handpie and Steak & Ale Handpie, perfect for a quick and satisfying snack on the go.
Additionally, Magpie Bakery invites guests to enjoy a selection of hot and iced drinks, including Cafe Mocha, Espresso, Cortado, and Americano. Whether you're craving a classic Cappuccino or a comforting Hot/Iced Latte, Magpie Bakery has something to satisfy every coffee lover's palate.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
5.042 reviews
Kasia C.
8/22/2025
Cute little bakery in Bloomingdale - lots of fresh pastries and cakes here. I had a raspberry and cheese danish that was very fresh and delicious!
Candice N.
7/9/2024
I found Magpie Bakery via a GF search on Yelp, and it definitely lived up to the hype! Loved meeting the owners and hearing their story of how and why they started their bakery. The cakes I had...
Lad B.
12/20/2024
Very nice locally owned bakery/coffee shop with a nice limited selection of pastries. Requests are happily accepted with notice. Priced a little higher than other bakeries in the area. Ample...
Nick P.
9/24/2025
The banana cream pie was such a hit at my family gathering, it caused a huge fight on who got to take the leftovers home and my sister in-law is still mad about it. 10/10 would order again
See a problem?
