The Baseball Card Store

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(22)

Call
Website

Photos

45 Prospect St
Midland Park, NJ 07432
+1 (201) 445-9007
http://www.baseballcardstorenj.com
The Baseball Card Store Inc is a local hobby shop located in Midland Park, NJ, celebrating its 22nd year in the same location. They offer a wide range of vintage and modern baseball, football, basketball, hockey, and wrestling cards, as well as Magic the Gathering and Pokemon cards. The store features a variety of featured items and monthly "pull of the month" highlights, showcasing exciting card pulls from customers. They also have a blog called Hairline Crease, run by sports card collector Dan, which covers topics related to sports cards, with a focus on baseball.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.522 reviews
Steven K.
5/12/2025

Best card shop around hands down. Been going to them for about 15 years. They also just remodeled/expanded the shop. Great work place, even better guys! Knowledgable, honest and always have a nice...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Clarissa D.
Clarissa D.
10/28/2023

Great cards at great prices:). Great selection of cards from every sport.+Nice staff also 1 free piece of bubblegum. I would definitely recommend for starting a collection.

Read more on Yelp
Aidan G.
9/2/2024

Good selection of anything you need sports card wise. Love going here for acouple packs or a nice box when i splurge. Prices are reasonable compared to other shops in the area, and the guys are...

Read more on Yelp
Ryan C.
12/28/2023

They are all nice except for one. they yelled at us and told us to leave when we were opening packs and it was 10 degrees out. we also didn't have a ride home and we lived 30 minutes away. overall...

Read more on Yelp
Howard V.
11/13/2024

i have a 1954 willie mays card in heay plastic casing i am getting different prices i need to know how much is it worth my email is garthbrooks211@yahoo.com

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Trading cards: baseball or other sports, entertainment, etc.

America's Pastime

America's Pastime is a prominent retail sports card store located in Fair Lawn, NJ, specializing in a vast collection of both current and vintage sports cards across baseball, football, basketball, and hockey. Established in 1989, the store offers an extensive inventory of graded and ungraded cards, autographed memorabilia, and hobby supplies, catering to collectors of all levels. In addition to a wide selection of merchandise, America's Pastime actively engages in buying sports cards and memorabilia, making it a go-to destination for enthusiasts looking to both purchase and sell valuable items. The store participates in various sports card shows throughout the year, further solidifying its reputation within the collecting community. Generated from the website
Sports Nut Cards
Trading cards: baseball or other sports, entertainment, etc.

Sports Nut Cards

5
"Old school sports card shop. Tables of boxes that you can thumb through. "....got it, got it, need it, got need it..." I need a couple of hours every time I go. Huge inventory, including a fair..."
photo of Noam F.
American Legends
Trading cards: baseball or other sports, entertainment, etc., Collectibles and antiques, mail order, Comic books

American Legends

18
•
$$$
"There is no more Complete Card Shop in the area. Hands Down. The BEST place to, not only get cards, but your supplies as well. The whole staff, not just the owners, are knowledgeable and always..."
photo of Anthony L.
United States›New Jersey›Midland Park›The Baseball Card Store

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.