Robert S.
10/16/2025
In a plaza in Colts Neck, you will find a bagel store with potential. Brand: 9/10 I do appreciate the cartoon bagel characters with the old-fashioned 1930s animation eyes painted on the glass...
The Bagel Store
Closed
(46)
Photos
340 State Route 34
Colts Neck, NJ 07722
The Bagel Store in Colts Neck, NJ is a local favorite known for their meticulously hand-rolled bagels made from scratch every day, using a classic bagel making oven. Their unmatched deliciousness attracts a loyal following, with many customers joining them each morning for their fix of fresh bagels and coffee.
Owned by a passionate fan of the Lord of the Rings franchise, The Bagel Store embraces a unique theme inspired by the series. Customers can enjoy a special discount by quoting a line from LOTR to Bagel Jesus, also known as Chris, who can be found at the store. With their commitment to quality and a touch of fandom, The Bagel Store offers a one-of-a-kind bagel experience in Colts Neck.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.546 reviews
Sophie T.
7/7/2025
Conveniently located next to Rook so you can grab a coffee next door and come here for a bagel. Also this is part of a plaza of stores so there's plenty of parking. I got a sausage, egg, and...
Mikayla P.
9/25/2025
This place is okay. With NJ having a ton of bagel shops I think there is a better place you can go and grab a bagel. The bagels are big but a bit flavorless in my opinion. If you are in a hurry...
Donna T.
6/8/2025
I am so sorry to be doing this but these were the most disgusting bagels we have had in a long time. I ordered two bagels a sesame and and an egg bagel toasted with butter..............what I got...
Maeve C.
4/16/2025
Went in to try this place and give it a chance despite bad reviews. Was utterly disappointed with the service and food. There was no hospitality whatsoever. I'm sure the woman working the register...
See a problem?
