Ron L.
7/29/2025
I live above NYC in southern Westchester County, NY, and I have a second home in Cape May. I have tried Everything bagels from various locations in and around NYC. The Everything bagels at The...
The Bagel Shop
Closed
(22)
Photos
3845 Bayshore Rd
Cape May, NJ 08204
The Bagel Shop in Cape May NJ is a cozy eatery known for its freshly baked bagels and delicious spreads. With a welcoming atmosphere it serves a variety of classic and creative bagel options perfect for breakfast or a quick snack. Whether you're a local or a visitor this charming spot is a must-try for bagel lovers.
Generated from this place's information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.522 reviews
Elizabeth O.
8/29/2025
Really good bagels! I had the deluxe chicken salad club on an everything bagel and my boyfriend had a pork roll egg and cheese on a plain bagel. Both sandwiches were great! I really liked the...
Chris g.
3/21/2025
Legit!!!! I grew up in N NJ and these bagels are phenomenal! Why am I the first to post about this??!' So much better than the other local with giant bagels that are dense and heavy (hint, they...
Elisabeth W.
8/31/2025
Bagels are good. I wish they were open more during the week. Maybe the rent is high, probably explains the 15 dollar breakfast sandwich. I folded once for it, I was hungover and needed to eat but...
Paul M.
4/13/2025
Was waiting for the Bagel Shop to open and it was worth the wait!! The interior is adorable with self serve bagels and a check out counter and seating as well. Tried the everything, black sesame...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.