Tony S.
6/29/2025
Great bagels. Tiny inside. If you are willing to wait in a huge line, it's worth it. I suggest order online and pickup on the right side.
The Bagel Shack
$
Closed
(103)
Photos
306 N Bay Ave
Beach Haven, NJ 08008
Bagels, Fresh Bagels Made On The Premises, Flagels, Bagel Chips, Pizza, O'Malley's Pizza, Beach Haven, Long Beach Island, NJ, Family Owned and Operated, Open 364 Days A Year, Green, Recycle Friendly, Coffee, Pork Roll, Lox, The Bagel Shack, Bagel Shack The Bagel Shack has been making it's bagels on the premises fresh daily, using our own recipe, for decades. Located in the heart of Beach Haven on Long Beach Island, NJ, the Shack is opened 364 days a year (closed only on the 25th of December). During the winter months our business hours are from 7:00 am - 2:00 pm and we re-open from 5:00 to 8:00 pm on Thurs., Fri. And Sat. Serving O'Malley's Pizza (also our own recipe) and more. We are family owned and operated and welcome suggestions/ideas from our customers. The Shack also prides itself in serving our community, our Townships and the Island.
Reviews
3.5103 reviews
Erin O.
1/12/2025
My favorite bagels on LBI! I've been visiting Bagel Shack since I was little and it has never failed to disappoint. Whether you're ordering a pork roll and egg sandwich or a bagel with a simple...
Trinity L.
7/27/2025
I got a salt bagel with garlic cream cheese, it was really good and I loved it! Although my boyfriend got the Bacon, Egg, and cheese, on a french toast bagel. He said it was decent and tasted Fast...
Rebecca V.
7/22/2025
Rude employees. Accidentally put salt in my coffee and they, thinking I couldn't hear, made fun of me for it behind the counter.
Patrick D.
7/6/2025
food is always good but I'm writing this review while i wait for my food as it's been about 25 minutes. They're very disorganized and seem to put online orders at the front of the line regardless...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.