Ken H.
9/26/2025
Wow just had great cupcakes. The brownies were not my thing. I need mine to be more cake like but try them for yourself. You may enjoy. Didn't even pay for 6 items because of my rewards points....
Supreme Bakery
$
Open
(141)
Photos
40 Main St
West Orange, NJ 07052
Supreme Bakery has been providing the freshest and finest bakery products to the residents of West Orange and surrounding areas since 1969.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5141 reviews
Nathalie M.
10/13/2025
Ordered the mini chocolate cake from Uber Eats. It was incredibly disappointing because it didn't have any buttercream inside. No layers or filling either. It was just a block of cake with...
Jason R.
3/14/2025
I received some cupcakes from here for my birthday. (Sorry no photos; they got smashed in the car, lol). Two of the cupcakes were smaller and the other was very large and I ate in two segments....
Ryanne M.
9/3/2025
Cake wasn't good at all I'm sorry but not sorry very disappointed because common not even one cake but the both of them it's sad because I couldn't even call that day because I had a fly the next...
Ameera A.
10/25/2024
IF I COULD RATE THIS BUSINESS A ZERO I WOULD! This was by far one of my WORST EXPERIENCES with customer service ever. I expressed my concerns with a gender reveal cake I received was offered a...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.