John A.
10/8/2025
Amazing food so fresh incredible I asked for a soup and they made it from scratch per order. Never saw this before highly recommend this restaurant five stars.
Stephanie's Italian Restaurant
$$
Closed
(140)
Photos
283 Bloomfield Ave
Caldwell, NJ 07006
Fish is always fresh. Great presentations. . Great Hosts. . . . delicious food and nice portion sizes.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0140 reviews
Thomas A.
1/11/2024
I have a dear friend (named Stephanie!) with an upcoming milestone birthday (cinquanta!) and figured a gift certificate from here would do the trick. (But first I'd need to do a bit of 'recon'...
Lauri P.
8/3/2023
We LOVE this place and come here weekly. BYOB which is always a huge plus. Food is delish and they always make Chicken Piccata for me, which is not on the menu. Beautiful and spacious outdoor...
Patricia M.
6/30/2023
Stephanie's has a cute outdoor sitting area when you enter through the back. The service from hostess to waitress is impeccable. The inside seating is a bit packed. I would have given them five...
Dawn C.
5/13/2025
Great food and soft ambiance. Food was good. Portions nice size. Cozy and relatively quiet restaurant. Will definitely go back.
See a problem?
