Scott S.
4/23/2025
Popped in to this cash only bagel place that I had seen listed in best NJ bagels. They are known for the French Toast bagel. Took it home and it lived up to the reviews. A strong French toast...
Sheepshead Baygels
$
Closed
(102)
Photos
2095 State Route 35
Holmdel, NJ 07733
Sheepshead Baygels is a popular bagel shop located on Route 35 in Holmdel, NJ, known for its inviting atmosphere and delicious offerings.
They serve freshly hand-rolled bagels daily, along with a variety of breakfast and lunch options, including coffee, wraps, soups, and a wide selection of cold cuts.
Generated from their available business information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5102 reviews
Glenn S.
4/12/2025
Very good bagels. The place has been around since 1974 and it looks like it but not in a bad way. The bagels are fresh and the mini bagels are delicious too. The shop pays homage to Brooklyn...
Stacey G.
6/30/2024
Great bagels and bagel sandwiches. Amazing coffee cake. Super friendly staff. Cash only
Paulie X K.
2/1/2025
2 stars based on the bagel itself. Very thick and doughy. Did not taste good either. Outside was kinda rubbery. Jaw started to hurt after eating half. Will most likely not be back. Still on the...
Melissa C.
6/9/2025
Absolute best bagels in NJ, no contest. Been coming here my entire life and I've yet to find a better bagel place. Always delicious and fresh, very generous with the spreads.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.